Topcoder-Platform/public-website-qa-bug-hunt
2
1
Fork 0
Code Issues 119 Pull Requests Wiki Activity

In Add Service Provider, clicking Edit with empty Service Provider Name switches form to “Add Service Provider” unexpectedly #133

New Issue
Open
opened 2025-09-22 03:52:49 -04:00 by mayur.joshi.dev.2 · 1 comment
mayur.joshi.dev.2 commented 2025-09-22 03:52:49 -04:00
Copy Link

Issue URL:

https://account-settings.topcoder.com/#tools

Steps to reproduce

  1. Go to https://www.topcoder.com
  2. Click "Account Settings"
  3. Go to "Tools" menu
  4. Scroll down to Service Provider
  5. Add a new service provider
  6. Now click on the edit icon next to it
  7. Without entering a service provider name (which is required), click on "Edit Service Provider to your List"

Actual result

Clicking the button without a value for Service Provider incorrectly switches the form into “Add Service Provider” mode instead of showing validation feedback.

Expected result

If “Service Provider Name” is left empty and user clicks the button, the system should either show a validation error or keep the user in the edit form until a valid value is entered.

Screenshots/Videos

Environment

  • OS and Browser version:
    MacOS Sonoma: Version 14.3.1
    Google Chrome: Version 140.0.7339.186 (Official Build) (x86_64)

  • Device: Macbook Pro

Reproducibility

5/5

#### Issue URL: https://account-settings.topcoder.com/#tools #### Steps to reproduce 1. Go to https://www.topcoder.com 2. Click "Account Settings" 3. Go to "Tools" menu 4. Scroll down to Service Provider 5. Add a new service provider 6. Now click on the edit icon next to it 7. Without entering a service provider name (which is required), click on "Edit Service Provider to your List" #### Actual result Clicking the button without a value for Service Provider incorrectly switches the form into “Add Service Provider” mode instead of showing validation feedback. #### Expected result If “Service Provider Name” is left empty and user clicks the button, the system should either show a validation error or keep the user in the edit form until a valid value is entered. #### Screenshots/Videos <video src="attachments/68375e96-3549-49fe-9fa2-224b531c7a0d" title="output.mp4" controls></video> #### Environment - OS and Browser version: MacOS Sonoma: Version 14.3.1 Google Chrome: Version 140.0.7339.186 (Official Build) (x86_64) - Device: Macbook Pro #### Reproducibility 5/5
output.mp4
1.8 MiB
mayur.joshi.dev.2 added the ChromeFunctionalMacOSUX labels 2025-09-22 03:53:02 -04:00
nithya160925 added validS: Low and removed UX labels 2025-09-24 11:13:02 -04:00
nithya160925 added the P: Account Settings label 2025-09-25 04:47:37 -04:00
nithya160925 commented 2025-09-26 08:59:59 -04:00
Collaborator
Copy Link

All the Edit buttons in the Tools page don't seem to be prepopulating values. Another relevant issue #150

We also need to validate for mandatory values while saving the edits.

All the Edit buttons in the Tools page don't seem to be prepopulating values. Another relevant issue #150 We also need to validate for mandatory values while saving the edits.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Branch/Tag Specified
Branches Tags
Labels
Clear labels
carousel
issues related to carousel on different pages
 Chrome
Content
An issue involving incorrect or outdated content
 data issue
duplicate
Edge
Firefox
Functional
An issue where a feature or function is not behaving as expected
 incomplete
incomplete steps, missing details
 Invalid
Issues that are not in scope, not reproducible, incomplete, etc
 MacOS
Not a bug
Out of Scope
P: Account Settings
P: AI Hub
P: Blog
P: Challenge Details Page
P: Challenge Listing Page
P: Customer Stories Page
P: Freelancers Page
P: Help page
P: Help Page
P: Homepage
P: Marathon Tournament Page
P: My Profile
P: Review Opportunities Page
P: SignUp flow
P: Statistics Page
P: Talent Page
P: Terms and Policies
P: Thrive
P: Topcoder Academy
P: Topcoder Customer Account
Safari
S: Critical
The issue causes data loss, a system crash, or a major part of the application to be unusable. A workaround may exist, but it is not acceptable for end-users.
 S: High
he issue is a significant bug that affects a key feature, causes incorrect behavior, or results in a poor user experience. It needs to be addressed soon.
 S: Low
A minor issue with minimal impact, such as a typo, misaligned element, or a cosmetic flaw.
 S: Medium
The issue is a noticeable problem, but it doesn't break core functionality. It might be a UI issue, a confusing error message, or a minor functional bug.
 Trivial
UI
An issue concerning a visual design and layout (Ex: button misaligned, text is overlapping)
 UX
An issue that negatively affects the user's journey or usability
 valid
Windows
No Label Chrome Functional MacOS P: Account Settings S: Low valid
Milestone
No items
No Milestone
Assignees
Clear assignees
kiril.kartunov nithya160925 tester1234
No Assignees
2 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: Topcoder-Platform/public-website-qa-bug-hunt#133
Delete Branch "%!s()"

Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?